Longford's Ice Cream-Rye Information

If you're ever in Rye, NY, and craving something sweet, there's a spot you absolutely can't miss-Longford's Ice Cream-Rye. Tucked away at 4 Elm Pl, this cozy little ice cream shop has earned a reputation as a local favorite, and for good reason. From the moment you walk in, you’re greeted with the mouth-watering scent of freshly made waffle cones and the sight of a colorful array of flavors that will have you staring at the menu longer than you expect.

The menu here is a treat in itself, offering everything from classic favorites like chocolate and vanilla to more adventurous options like salted caramel pretzel and lemon meringue pie. One of the things that really stands out about Longford's Ice Cream-Rye is the quality of their ingredients. The ice cream is rich, creamy, and made with care, giving each scoop a dense, satisfying texture that you don’t often find in chain ice cream shops. There’s something so comforting about the fact that you’re eating ice cream made by people who truly know what they’re doing.

What makes this place even better is the friendly atmosphere. The staff are always happy to chat and offer recommendations, which is a big plus when you’re overwhelmed by the tempting choices. It’s the kind of place where you feel like a regular after just one visit. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, there’s a welcoming vibe that makes you want to linger, even if you’ve already finished your cone.

The location itself is small but charming, with just enough room to grab your treat and enjoy it either inside or out. On a sunny day, the outdoor seating area becomes the perfect spot to enjoy your ice cream while soaking in the sights and sounds of Rye. It's the kind of place where families, friends, and solo visitors alike can enjoy a relaxing afternoon with a scoop of something delicious.

For those with dietary restrictions or preferences, Longford's Ice Cream-Rye has you covered. They offer a few dairy-free options, and you can also find some lower-sugar varieties. But no matter your preference, there’s always a flavor to satisfy every palate. Whether you’re indulging in a traditional sundae or going for a scoop in a freshly made cone, you’re in for a treat that will have you coming back for more.

If you haven’t yet made your way to Longford's Ice Cream-Rye, it’s time to pay them a visit. It's the kind of place that keeps you coming back for the sweet, creamy ice cream, the charming vibe, and the feeling that you've found a little gem in the heart of Rye.

Business Info

What People's Say About Place

Customer from 1997 out of the small factory in Port Chester. This lil gem in Rye is to die for. Longford's Ice Cream is where your sweet dreams and sweet tooth come true.

A delicious Ice Cream spot! Longford's Rye has SO many great options to pick from. The staff is very friendly and mainly high-school/college kids (which is great). They also offer candy and other goodies as well. One thing to note, it's very $$$. I cost $15 for 2 cups of ice cream. The ice cream was worth it, but I won't be coming here weekly I'll visit again sometime! P.S: night time crowds bring a 10-15 minute waiting line for the ice cream Overall Rating: 10/10

We bought a cookie monster, pistachio, cotton candy, and espresso nugget. The ice cream was flavorful and not overly sweet. There are also candy of all kinds. They provided samples and that was a good thing because who likes to get an ice cream flavor that you were debating about and not like it? Plus there are at least 10 to 20 wonderful flavors to choose from! Longford’s Ice Cream RYE is great and i would highly reccomend it to anybody!

Longfords is a must for myself and my family anytime we are in Rye especially after the beach. Longfords has a great selection of flavors and the moose tracks and cappucino in a waffle cone with sprinkles is my personal fav

**min $10 to use credit cards ** Nice location, friendly staff, good variety and tasty of ice cream. I liked that they offered a sample to try before your purchase. I enjoyed the Graham Cracker, and Espresso Nugget. I didn’t like the min order amount before you can use a credit card.

Lonford’s Ice Cream. We went with family after dinner in downtown Rye, NY. Great place for the whole family. Lots of various ice cream to choose from and sorbet. Downtown Rye is decorated beautifully for Christmas. Everybody loved their selections. Right off Main Street close to all the main restaurants.

Delicious ice cream with rich flavors and creamy texture. Absolutely worth the visit! The lines can be long, but they move quickly, which just proves how popular this place is. Friendly service Highly recommend!

Some colleagues wanted to go out for ice cream, and I didn't want to tell them I usually don't. But the staff here was really great getting me set up with a non-dairy option that was delicious! It's got more than just ice cream, with an old-fashioned candy store feel to it. It was busy but the staff was pleasant and hustled to get everyone what they needed. Definitely would recommend

Longford's Ice Cream-Rye